When the 1869 Hallmark House at 142 E. First St. was on the market, its listing agent said buyers at the open house were more interested in its 0.69-acre lot than in the house. "The land is more valuable," she told The Hinsdalean. The seller was Grace Episcopal Church, and the buyer was a builder, Legacy Homes.
That sale follows the pattern behind most new housing in Hinsdale over the past two years. The new homes go up in batches on a few large parcels that churches, a school, a religious institute and a private estate gave up. If you want a new home in this village, you're picking from a short list of named projects. Their recorded prices show the land and the address setting the price far more than the square footage does.
Where Hinsdale's new homes came from
In September 2025, The Hinsdalean counted 14 new single-family homes and seven condominiums being built or sold in Hinsdale. Here is where they came from:
- The Oaks, 620 N. Oak St.: the former site of Hinsdale Baptist Church, 1.7 acres that the Village Board rezoned for single-family homes in August 2025.
- The Vine, 125 S. Vine St.: the old Zion Lutheran School. The church agreed to sell the property in 2022.
- 142 E. First St.: the Hallmark House, sold by Grace Episcopal.
- The Preserves of Hinsdale, 4S010 Madison St.: 34.84 acres at Ogden Avenue and Adams Street that the Institute of Basic Life Principles sold to new owners in 2025.
- 505 S. County Line Road: the 22-room Krehbiel mansion. Its 2.76 acres sold for $7.5 million in 2022, and the house was gone by October 2025.
Kensington Court, near Ogden and Monroe, adds a sixth cluster: eight homes on 2.2 acres.
Large parcels like these don't come up often, and when one does, a builder can put up several houses at once. That's why new construction here arrives in waves. The rest of the village mostly turns over one older house at a time.
The Vine sells condos at house prices
The clearest pricing evidence comes from the former Zion School at Second and Vine. Holladay Properties of Clarendon Hills and Hinsdale's Ross Builders turned the 95-year-old building into six condominiums for buyers 55 and older. The building has underground parking, a shared outdoor space, and units of 1,594 to 2,836 square feet. The plan started at 12 units, came down to seven, then to six after one buyer combined two units.
DuPage County deeds recorded between Sept. 22 and Sept. 25, 2026 show four sales at The Vine: $2,445,029, $2,574,263, $2,697,485, and $4,689,140 for the combined unit. The same Hinsdalean deed roundup lists two single-family resales from that week: 915 S. Madison St. at $2,437,000 and 1411 Hawthorne Lane at $2,650,000.
So in late September 2026, a single condo of under 3,000 square feet in a converted school recorded about the same price as a Hinsdale house. Those buyers paid for staying in town and for a home with no upkeep. According to Craig Ross, half the units sold before they were formally listed. "There's just a lot of demand for a turnkey condo, because a lot of older couples want to stay in town for their kids and grandkids but don't want a 4,000- or 5,000-square-foot house," he told The Hinsdalean.
Mike Doyle of Holladay explained in the same story what that means for everyone else: downsizers "stay in town. And their home becomes available for new families moving to town." If you're shopping for a family-size house in Hinsdale, some of your supply depends on projects like The Vine. If you're downsizing in town, there were six units in this building, and most had closed by September.
What builder sales on Kensington Court recorded
Kensington Court is home to The Eight, which its listing agent described to The Hinsdalean in September 2025 as "the only gated new construction community in Hinsdale." The homes have an HOA and maintenance-free grounds. Some have first-floor primary bedrooms and some have four bedrooms upstairs. J Jordan Homes built them with MK Construction and Moment Design, and the advertised starting price was $2.6 million.
The 2026 deeds are worth reading against that starting price. MK Construction sold 531 Kensington Court for $2,345,000 on Aug. 27. On Sept. 25 it sold 537 Kensington Court for $2,235,000 and 539 Kensington Court for $2,100,000.
All three builder sales closed below the 2025 advertised start. They also landed right around the 915 S. Madison resale and below The Vine's single-unit sales. Leave out The Vine's $4.7 million combined unit and put the gated cluster, the converted school and a regular resale side by side, and in August and September 2026 they all recorded between about $2.1 million and $2.7 million. A buyer in Hinsdale was paying a similar price whether the home was new or old, a house or a condo. What changed was the lifestyle, from yard work to no maintenance at all.
The bigger parcels behind these
The church and institute sites beyond Kensington Court and The Vine hold larger homes on larger lots.
At The Oaks, Oakley Home Builders of Downers Grove planned six homes on the old Hinsdale Baptist Church site. In September 2025 the builder expected them to be at least 5,000 square feet and sell for $3 million to $4 million. At that point co-owner Steve Sobkowiak described utilities and stormwater work underway, with two spec homes planned facing Oak and presold homes on Franklin. The site plan originally had seven homes and came down to six because one family bought two lots.
The Preserves of Hinsdale is bigger. The July 2026 proposal has 20 single-family homes and a 15.5-acre park on the former IBLP land. The park would be owned by the homeowners association and open to the public. Twelve homes would sit on a cul-de-sac named Preserve Place, seven would face Adams Street, and a 2.83-acre lot off Madison Street would be developed later. Trustee Luke Stifflear said the lots would average more than 32,000 square feet. The Village Board voted 5-0 to send the plan to the plan commission. Belmont Village Senior Living and McNaughton Development have also floated senior living on 13 IBLP acres to the west.
Older houses on big lots are priced as land
Outside the clusters, a new house usually starts with a builder buying an older one for its lot. At 142 E. First St., Legacy Homes planned a 6,841-square-foot transitional French-country house to replace the Hallmark House.
On the Krehbiel land at 505 S. County Line Road, the village issued Timber Trails Building a permit for a new single-family home on March 24, 2026, with an estimated project cost of $2 million. In 2022 that 2.76-acre parcel sold for $7.5 million. The October 2025 Hinsdalean article estimated three replacement houses could bring $12 million.
If you're looking at an older house on a generous lot in Hinsdale, assume builders are pricing the same listing. After the Hallmark House sale, the chair of the village's preservation commission said a lower price aimed at renovation might have drawn a buyer who wanted to restore it. When the price reflects the land, the buyer who will build new can usually pay more than the buyer who wants to renovate.
How to shop new construction here
In practice, that leaves you three choices. Buy in a cluster like Kensington Court, where builder sales recorded $2.1 million to $2.35 million in August and September 2026. Watch the larger church and institute parcels, where homes are bigger and the builder's September 2025 estimate at The Oaks ran $3 million to $4 million. Or buy an older house on its own lot and price it as land, knowing a builder may be bidding too. For downsizers who want to stay in town, The Vine set the benchmark: its single units recorded about $2.4 million to $2.7 million in September 2026, close to what a single-family house went for, and its combined unit recorded $4.7 million.
If you'd rather get into one of these batches before it sells out than read about it in the deed records afterward, talk to us. Matt Laricy and the Hinsdale team keep tabs on these builders and parcels. If you're the downsizer whose house would free up for the next family, we'll price it against what the land, the builders and this fall's closings support. Start with a home valuation. List with Laricy: sell faster, reach more buyers.